Who Killed Sir Harry Oakes?

Product Information

The Bahamas’ governor, the Duke of Windsor (formerly King Edward VIII of the United Kingdom), who had become a close friend of Oakes during the previous three years, took charge of the investigation from the outset. The Duke first attempted to enforce press censorship, but this was unsuccessful, since the Bahamas Tribune newspaper broke the story to the world within a few hours. [17] Oakes' vast wealth, fame and British title, combined with the ghastly nature of the crime, generated worldwide interest in the case. Etienne Dupuch, the colony's foremost newspaper publisher and a close friend of Oakes, ensured constant coverage of the case for the several months which followed. [2] Dupuch had called the Oakes residence early on the morning after the crime, since he had previously arranged to visit, and spoke with Harold Christie, who had stayed there overnight; Christie reported the death to Dupuch. [18] Harry angled for a seat in Canada’s upper house of Parliament. He went so far as to renounce his U.S. citizenship, but he was denied by the prime minister. He became increasingly furious at Canada’s tax system, and at the failure of the government to appreciate the wealth he generated. Harold Christie had numerous loans with Oakes. Had Oakes called in those loans, Christie would have been wiped out. Police said Oakes likely had died between 1 a.m. and 3 a.m., and a woman had sworn that in the early hours of June 8, she saw Christie, who should have been snoring at Oakes’ place, driving along a downtown street. Oakes bought the British Colonial Hotel and 10,000 acres of land on New Providence. He built two palatial mansions, one on Cable Beach named Westbourne, and another at the Caves. A murder had been committed, and its investigation would reveal dark secrets that many of the island’s inhabitants would have preferred to remain hidden.

He was portrayed by Scott Hylands in "Rex v De Marigny", a 1993 dramatization of the murder trial for the Canadian drama anthology series Scales of Justice. [25] Niagara Falls: Investments and philanthropy [ edit ] Oakes Park [ edit ]Gardner wrote that “Perry Mason, pacing the floor, points to certain places where the testimony fails to etch the murder’s shadow into a clear outline.” And as I discovered while researching my new book, The Windsors at War: The Nazi Threat to the Crown, not everyone was delighted to be there. Two of the most reluctant residents in fact were the 49-year-old Governor of the Bahamas – the Duke of Windsor, the former King Edward VIII – and his 47-year-old wife, Wallis Simpson. Harry Oakes has a small dinner party at his residence, Westbourne. Four people are there, including Oakes and Christie.

Alfred de Marigny had, in fact, argued several times with Sir Harry. But so had almost everyone who knew him. Freddy didn’t have an airtight alibi for the murder, but no one had seen him around Sir Harry’s house the night of the murder. The question arose: Didn’t he and Nancy stand to inherit millions if Sir Harry died? Police pounced on Freddy and charged him with murder. Framed

Lion Television, Murder in Paradise". Archived from the original on 12 February 2007 . Retrieved 8 December 2006. The duke wrote in August that the playboy was “a despicable character… with the worst possible record, morally and financially, since his adolescence.” It was known, for instance, that de Marigny had threatened to “smash in” his father-in-law’s head during one especially heated argument. The trial lasted 22 days. on Nov. 11, jurors deliberated for an hour and 55 minutes. The verdict: Not guilty.

Do grown men usually do that? Do they rush into each-other’s bedrooms at the first sign of daylight, to wake each other up, like school girls, after a sleepover? Miss Betty Renner, a Washington Lawyer, was investigating the murder of Harry Oakes which had occurred seven years before on 7th July 1943. Renner was department of justice lawyer. Renner had become obsessed with Oakes murder. Oakes graduated from Foxcroft Academy in Dover-Foxcroft, Maine, founded in 1823, three years after statehood, one of the very few public high school "academies" left in Maine. The present campus is on the former Oakes farm on outer Main Street on the way to Sangerville, his birthplace. Only person left is Mrs. Newell Kelly wife of property manager. Husband is away. Mrs. Kelly lives in the guest house with her mother. The guest house is away from the main house.De Marigny didn’t make things easy for himself. He couldn’t find the shirt and tie he wore that night. He allegedly told a police official “the old (expletive) should have been killed anyhow.” He asked investigators if a person could be convicted of murder on circumstantial evidence alone, without a weapon. And he admitted he’d removed several cans of gasoline from his home the day Sir Harry was bludgeoned and set afire. Nancy had learned of her father’s death when she was on her way from Miami to Martha Graham’s dance studio in Bennington, Vt. Her friend Merce Cunningham gave her the news. Nancy changed her plans and flew to Bar Harbor to join her mother at the funeral. The trial of Alfred deMarigny, Oakes' son-in-law, made international news and his eventual acquittal left the case unsolved -- it remains unsolved today. Let us not forget the recurring legend of all the “unexplained killings of people directly, or indirectly, involved” with the Harry Oakes murder. (Marquis 6) The plot was perfect. There was blood and the thunder of a rampaging tropical storm,” Gardner said. “Who could need more?” The only explanation for it all, was that they were lovers. The Oakes murder puzzle becomes that much more complete, if serious considerations are given to the very plausible explanation, that the two men were lovers.

Christie dismissed Oakes’ two night watchmen. Tells them to go home. The cook, Mrs. Fernandez and the maid Mabel Ellis both go home. This may sound too good to be true. It may sound like the plot to a best-selling pot-boiler. And it all serves to explain the continuing interest in the murder of Sir Harry Oakes, often referred to, hyperbolically (and hyperbole is in no short supply in the coverage of the murder), as "the crime of the century." (deMarigny 41) By most accounts, Freddy and Harry’s relationship was neither especially friendly nor unfriendly. After announcing their elopement, Freddy and Nancy were invited to Bar Harbor for their honeymoon. There, the Oakes family welcomed them politely, if not warmly. Freddy got along well with Nancy’s four siblings, taking them sailing off the Maine coast.

Share this article

It was a small, three-pronged instrument of some sort judging by the injuries to his head. It was never found and this is one of the criticisms levelled at the American detectives.